Minkowski on mathematician and physicist

12月 19, 2012

Minkowski concluded this section with a remark that
clarifies his understanding of the basic motivations behind Einstein’s contribution to the
latest developments in electrodynamics: mathematicians—Minkowski said—accustomed
as they are to discuss many-dimensional manifolds and non-Euclidean geometries, will
have no serious difficulties in adapting their concept of time to the new one, implied by
the application of the Lorentz transformation; on the other hand, the task of making physical
sense out of the essence of these transformations had been addressed by Einstein in the
introduction to his 1905 relativity article.26


Time is Relative

10月 7, 2012

http://www.ram.org/ramblings/ramblings.html


I recently had an argument about why time is relative. My friend found it hard to conceive how time could not be absolute. At that time, when I tried to explain it, I found that it was hard for me see WHY time really is relative. All I could do was state experimental results that indicate it is the case. This shows that thinking you can understand a deep concept at a very shallow, philosophical level doesn’t really mean much, but at least it’s better than no understanding at all.

Newton’s laws put an end to the idea of absolute motion. Two people playing ping pong on a moving train would measure the distance the ball bounces on the table (between consequecutive bounce) as lesser than a person standing along the track watching the ball bounce. Both measurements are equally valid since there is no absolute standard of rest.

Maxwell’s equations predicted that light waves travel at a fixed speed. This is something we have to believe, and it arises out of the fact that his equations predicted “there would be wavelike disturbances in the combined electromagnetic field, and that these would travel at a fixed speed, like ripples on a pond.”

But Newton’s theory got rid of the idea of absolute rest and if we believe that there’s no ambiguity about time, then if light is supposed to travel at a fixed speed, we need say what the fixed speed is measured relative to. It was suggested that there was a substance called “ether” that was present everywhere (even in “empty space”) and that light waves travelled through this ether at a fixed speed. However, different observers, moving relative to the ether, would see light coming at them at different speeds.

The way to verify this is to measure the speed of light as the earth moves through the ether on its orbit around the sun. So, light speed measured in the direction of earth’s orbit (when we are moving towards the source of light) should be higher than the speed of light measured at right angles from the direction of earth’s motion (when we are not moving towards the source of light). This experiment, called the Michaelson-Morley experiment, was performed in 1887, and to their great surprise, it was shown that the speed of light was exactly the same in both cases!

Einstein then pointed out that the whole idea of ether was unnecessary as long as one was willing to abandon the idea of absolute time. He postulated that the laws of science should be the same for all freely moving observers regardless of the speed. This was true for Newton’s laws of motion, but it also now applied to Maxwell’s theory and the speed of light: all observers should measure the same speed of light, no matter how fast they are moving.

One of the remarkable consequences of this theory is that how it has changed our thinking regarding space and time. In Newton’s theory, if a pulse of light is sent from one place to another, different observers would agree on the time the journey took (since time is absolute) but will not agree on how far the light travelled (since space is not absolute). Since the speed of light is measured as distance travelled/time taken, different observers would measure different speeds for the speed of light. But this clearly violates what Maxwell’s equations say and what has been shown by experiment. In relativity, all observers MUST agree on how fast light travels, but they don’t have to agree regarding the distance and consequently, they must disagree over the time it has taken! (The time taken is the distance (which they don’t agree on) divided by the speed of light (which they do agree on).) That is, observers must have their own measure of time, as recorded by a clock carried by them and even identical clocks carried by different observers would not necessarily agree.

From all this we can make the statement that time MUST be relative, because if it weren’t, it would contradict experimental results. But this doesn’t, at least to me, shed light on WHY this is the case. This might be a question more metaphysical than physical (i.e., time is relative just as Newton’s laws are the way they are). I shall attempt to address my question of “WHY” in greater detail now. (Though ultimately I don’t have a good answer I think—anyone?)

This theory (special relativity) and the more general form (which takes gravitional effects into account) of it makes several other important predictions which have withstood empirical observations. But one of the prediction of general relativity is time should appear to run slower near a massive body like the earth. This is because the energy of light is proportional its frequency (waves/second). As light travels upward in earth’s gravitional field, it loses energy, and therefore its frequency goes down. (The length of time between one wave crest and the next goes up.) To someone high up, it would appear that that everything down below was taking longer to happen. Apparently, this prediction can be tested by using a pair of very accurate clocks, one at the bottom nearer to the earth, and the other at the top. This was done in 1962, and the clock at the bottom was found to run slower, in exact agreement with general relativity! This is of practical importance, if you wish to trust navigational signals from satellites. If you ignore relativistic effects, you could be off by several miles!

Now, my question is, what is the basis for this phenomenon? Why should the clocks have different times? Why should it be related to light and its frequency? This is saying that time slows down when it is exposed to intense gravity. Why is this the case?

Similarly consider the twins paradox where one twin flies off into space at the speed of light and comes back and hasn’t aged much more than the twin who is on earth. It’s not a paradox if you have relative time, but what is the physiological basis (do the cells actually undergo cell division slower?) for this phenomenon?

We must accept that time isn’t independent of space and it forms a 4-dimensional construct called space-time. General relativity shows that gravity is really not a force, but rather a consequence of the fact that space-time is curved due to the distribution of mass and energy. Bodies like the earth don’t follow a curved orbit due to a force called gravity, but they follow the nearest thing to a straight path in curved space, called a geodesic. On the surface of the earth, a geodesic is a circle (the equator, for example). In general relativity, bodies always follow straight lines in four-dimensional space-time, but they appear to us to move along curved paths in three-dimensional space. (Hawking says this is like watching an airplane over an hilly ground. Although it follows a straight line in 3D space, its shadow follows a curved path on the ground.)

I imagine this as a huge rubber sheet with bodies like the sun, the earth, etc. are laying on the sheet causing a depression (a “gravity well”). An object travelling through this sheet might just go past the end of a well, causing it follow a curved path as thought it suffered a gravitional pull. An object might also just go inside the well and follow an elliptical path around the walls of the well. An object may finally, due to friction, decay and eventually fall in the greater object at the bottom of the well.

A postulate of general relativity, which follows from logical deductions, is that if two events are close together, there is an interval between them which can be calculated by some function of their coordinates. We know, according to the mathematics of the theory, that if we choose a region of space-time where the gravitation is the same throughout the region, that we can obtain very nearly a Euclidean space. We have a second postulate which states that a body travels in a geodesic in space-time unless non-gravitional forces act on it. The third postulate says that light travels on a geodesic such that the interval between any parts of it is zero.

In the general theory, It is only neighbouring events that have a definite interval and this is INDEPENDENT of the route pursued. The interval between distant events depends on the route pursued, and it can be calculated by dividing up the route into small enough parts (each part has constant gravitional effects and thus we can calculate the interval between the two neighbouring events), and adding up the intervals for all parts. If the interval is spacelike, a body cannot travel from one event to the other. Therefore, the interval has to be timelike. The interval between neighbouring events when it is timelike is the time between them for observers who travel from one event to the other. And so the TOTAL interval between two events will be judged by people who travel from one of the other by what their clocks show to to be the time they have taken on the journey. The slower they travel, the longer they will think they have been on the journey. This is not platitude—if you travel from DC to NY and leave at 6a and arrive at 10a, the more slowly you travel, the longer you will take according to your watch. So if you travel at the speed of light (third postulate), going all across the solar system before reaching your destination, your watch would say that you had taken no time at all! If you had gone by any circuitous route, which enabled you arrive in time by travelling fast, the longer your route the less time you will take. The diminision of time is continual as you approach the speed of light.

A body when left to itself travels so that the time, measured by its clocks, is the longest. If it had travelled by any other route from one event to another, the time would be shorter. This is saying that bodies left to themselves make their journeys as slowly as they can. Russell refers to this as a law of cosmic laziness. Mathematically, they travel in geodesics, in which the total interval between any two events on the journey is GREATER than by any other alternative route. (The fact that it is greater and not less is because the sort of interval we are considering is more analogous to time than to distance.) So, if someone flies off into space and comes back to earth after a while, the time between departure and return would be less by their clocks than by the clocks on earth, since the earth, during its journey around the sun, chooses the route so that any bit of it is measured longer than any other alternative route.

“Space and time are now dynamic quantities: when a body moves, or a force acts, it affects the curvature of space and time—and in turn the curvature of space-time affects the way in which bodies move and forces act. Space and time not only affect, but are also affected by everything that that happens in the universe.” Hofstadter would call this a Strange Loop.


References

  • A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking
  • Einstein’s Law of Gravition by Bertrand Russell
  • The Two Masses by Isaac Asimov

Pseudointellectual ramblings || Ram Samudrala || me@ram.org


Inertialsystem that is accelerating

9月 9, 2012

Inertialsystem that is accelerating


Einstein and Tummler, his sailing yacht

7月 29, 2012

Einstein and Tummler, his sailing yacht


In general relativity, there is no gravitational force. Gravity is geometry

7月 28, 2012

In general relativity, there is no gravitational force. Gravity is geometry.

It’s similar for the clocks in the spaceship. The signal that the group at the front receives is “Doppler-shifted” to stretched waves because these scientists are moving away. Their detector counts fewer of these stretched waves per second, and the scientists conclude that the clock in the back of the ship runs more slowly than the clock at the front.
To confirm, the group of scientists at the back of the ship detects the light from the front clock. Because this group is accelerating toward the place where the signal was emitted, they detect a compressed wave, and their detector counts more of these waves per second. For them, the clock at the front runs faster than theirs. The two groups are in agreement about the clocks


Lorentz-Fitzgerald Contraction

7月 14, 2012

In 1889, the Irish physicist George Francis Fitzgerald proposed
a radical explanation of why the Michelson-Morley
experiment failed to detect the luminiferous ether. His
explanation came at a time when he, like most scientists,
firmly believed in the ether. Movement through the ether,
Fitzgerald said, shortened the arm of Michelson’s interferometer
just enough to cancel the decrease in the speed
of light caused by the ether wind. This length contraction
took place along the line of motion and was almost impossible
to detect because any meter stick used to measure it
would contract, too.
Two years after Fitzgerald published his proposal, Hendrik
Lorentz, a prominent Dutch physicist who was also a
staunch believer in the ether, developed the idea further.
The shortening of objects in motion relative to an observer
became known as the Lorentz-Fitzgerald contraction.
Lorentz also came up with a general method for transforming
the space and time coordinates of events from one
inertial frame of reference to another. The equations he
derived to do this are called Lorentz transformations, and
they proved useful to Einstein as he developed the special
theory.
Lorentz’s formulas for calculating time dilation and
length contraction are identical to those Einstein developed
for special relativity. Why, then, are Lorentz and Fitzgerald
not considered to be the authors of the theory of special
relativity? The answer lies in the two men’s wrong interpretation
of the Michelson-Morley experiment. According
to Lorentz and Fitzgerald, the ether existed and the speed
of light was constant relative to it. Einstein’s bold leap forward
was to ignore the ether and accept what Maxwell’s
equations were telling him: The speed of light is the same
for every observer. It is this key conclusion that led Einstein
to relativity—and kept Lorentz and Fitzgerald from discovering
it themselves.

Nevertheless, Einstein knew he owed much to the two
men’s groundbreaking ideas and was quick to recognize
them. In an after-dinner speech he delivered in California,
Einstein credited “the ideas of Lorentz and Fitzgerald, out
of which the Special Theory of Relativity developed.”


Lorentz took the distortions that he discovered in fast-moving material objects to be laws of nature

7月 12, 2012

Time dilation. There is, however, another distortion that material objects undergo as a function of their absolute motion. That is a slowing down of clocks (and physical processes generally) at the same rate as the length contractions, or the so-called “time dilation,” which took somewhat longer for Lorentz to discover.

The Galilean transformation for time in Newtonian physics is simply t = t’ , because Newtonian physics assumes that time is the same everywhere. But by using transformation equations to describe the distortions in material objects, Lorentz found that he had to introduce a special equation for transforming time: t’ = t – vx/c2  (Goldberg, p. 94). The new factor in the transformation equation, vx/c2, implied that time on the moving frame varies with location in that frame. Lorentz called it “local time,” but he did not attribute any physical significance to it. “Local time” is not compatible with the belief in absolute space and time, and Lorentz described it as “no more than an auxiliary mathematical quantity” (Torretti, p. 45, 85), insisting that his transformation equations were merely “an aid to calculation” (Goldberg, p. 96).

The slowing down of physical processes is called “time dilation.” Lorentz discovered this distortion by tinkering with various ways of calculating the coordinates used on inertial reference frames in relative motion. Thus, it is natural to describe time dilation as the slowing down of clocks on the moving reference frame. It was included in the final version of Lorentz’s explanation, now called the “Lorentz transformation equations.” (Lorentz 1904) Those equations contained not only the length contraction and transformation for “local time”, but also the implication that clocks on moving frames are slowed down at the same rate as lengths are contracted (that is, ). The final Lorentz equation for time transformation included both the variation in local time and time dilation: .

Though Lorentz took the distortions that he discovered in fast-moving material objects to be laws of nature, he did not think that they were basic. He thought they were effects of motion on the interactions between electrons and the ether which could be explained by his electronic theory of matter, and he saw explaining this effect as the the main challenge to Newtonian physics. The transformation equations themselves never seemed puzzling to Lorentz, because he never took them to more than just a mathematical aid to calculation.


Criteria for a Good Theory in Physical Science

7月 20, 2011

A now famous instance of this sort appears
in the publication (1939) by Otto Hahn and
Fritz Strassmann, who originally (but unfairly)
received all the credit for the experimental discovery
of nuclear fission. At that time it was
still axiomatic in the thinking of many scientists
that nonradioactive atomic nuclei are stable,
that bombardment with small particles (e.g.,
neutrons) may at best dislodge an alpha particle
or two. But these two men, after firing neutrons
into pure uranium, were left with material that
by chemical test was proved to contain barium
(Ba) and other elements whose atoms are about
half as large as uranium atoms-“evidently” as
we would say now, the result of splitting uranium
atoms. But in an almost agonized expression of
the labor pains attending the birth of all great
recognitions, Hahn and Strassmann could not
dare to accept publicly the evidence of their own
chemical experiments, and so they wrote:
As ‘nuclear chemists,’ in many ways closely
associated with physics, we cannot yet bring
ourselves to make this leap in contradiction to
all previous lessons of nuclear physics. Perhaps,
after all, our results have been rendered deceptive
by some chain of strange accidents.
(“Concerning the existence … ,”
Naturwissenschaften)

A note on the human dimension behind scientific
publications: It was their colleague Lise
Meitner, forced to leave Germany by Nazi
assaults on Jews, who first recognized that the
Hahn-Strassman observations implied nuclear
fission, and with her nephew Otto Frisch worked
out the first rough theory of the process. Yet
Meitner was denied a share of the Nobel Prize
for the discovery, and she was only much later
given some recognition for it.


Coriolis force

12月 6, 2010

Wonders of physics

L G. AslamazovLate Professor, Moscow Technological UniversityA. A. VarlamovItalian Institute of Condensed Matter Physics

First let us consider the motion of our hero in a stationary reference
frame. Obviously the motion is circular with the linear velocity v that adds
up of the linear velocity u r of the merry-go round and his relative velocity:
v — uir + vo.
dG. G. Coriolis, (1792-1843), French civil engineer.
eSee the novel by M. Cruz-Smith for further reference.
44 The Fucault pendulum and the Baer law
The centripetal acceleration is denned by the common formula,
v v
aCT> = — = — + w 2 r + 2v0u>.
r r
According to the second Newton law the acceleration is due to the horizontal
component of the force exerted onto the man by the rotating platform, the
seat, handles etc.,
macp = Q.
Now consider the motion in the reference frame bound to the merry-goround.
Here the linear velocity is vo and the centripetal acceleration is
2
acp = ~f~- With the help of the two previous equalities we may write:
mvo ^ 2
maco = = Q — mcj r — 2mi>ow.
r
In order to apply the second Newton law in the revolving frame of reference
we must introduce the force of inertia:
F\n = – (m ui2 r + 2m v0 w) = – (Fct + Fcor),
where the minus sign indicates that it is directed away from the axis. In
the non-inertial frame the equation of motion will be:
m o^p = Q + Fi n = Q – (Fct + FCor).
It seems that the inertia force throws you of the center of the merry-goround.
However the word “seems” is not a slip. No new interactions between
the bodies appear in the rotating reference frame. The only real
forces acting onto the man are the same reactions of the seat and bars.
Their net horizontal component Q is directed towards the center. In the
stationary reference frame the force Q resulted into the centripetal acceleration
acp. In the rotating frame due to kinematical reasons the acceleration
changed to the smaller value a’cp. In order to restore the balance between
the two sides of the equation we had to introduce the force of inertia.
In our case the force Fin comes up of the two addends. The first is the
centrifugal force Fcf that increases with the frequency of rotation and with
the distance from the center. The second is the Coriolis force FQ0T named
after the person who first calculated it. This force has to be introduced
only when the body moves relative to the rotating frame. It depends not
Inertia forces in the rotating reference frame 45
on the position of the body but on it’s velocity and the angular velocity of
rotation.
If the body in the rotating frame moves not along a circle but radially,
Fig. 6.2, then, just the same, one must introduce the Coriolis force. Now
it is perpendicular to the radius unlike the previous case. One of the basic
features of the Coriolis force is that it is always perpendicular both to the
axis of rotation and to the direction of motion. It may look strange but
in the revolving frame inertia forces not only push a body away from the
center but tend to swerve it astray.
We must emphasize that the Coriolis force like all other inertia forces is
of kinematical origin and can not be related to any physical objects*. Here
is an explicit example.

Imagine a cannon set at the North pole and pointed along a meridian(the pole is chosen for simplicity). Let the target lie on the same meridian.Is it possible that the projectile hits the target? From the point of view ofexternal observer which uses the inertial frame bound to the Sun the answeris obvious: the trajectory of the projectile lies in the initial meridional planewhereas the aim revolves with the Earth. Thus the projectile will never getthe target (unless a whole number of days will elapse). But how could oneexplain the fact in the reference frame bound to the Earth? What causesthe projectile stray from the initial vertical plane? In order to restoreconsistency one has to introduce the Coriolis force that is perpendicularto the rotation axis and to the velocity of a body. This force pulls theprojectile away from the meridional plane and it misses the target.Now let us return to the precession of the oscillation plane of the Fucaultpendulum from which we have started. It comes of a quite similarreason. Suppose again that the pendulum is situated at the pole. Then fora stationary observer the oscillation plane is at rest and it is the Earth thatrotates. A denizen of the North pole will see the opposite. For him themeridional plane looks fixed whereas the oscillation plane of the pendulumperforms a full revolution every 24 hours. The only way to explain this iswith the help of the Coriolis force. Unfortunately in general the picture isnot so transparent as at the poleg.

fEven though the force of inertia is not produced by any real bodies, observers feel it asa real force, akin to gravity. Remember the centrifugal force in the turning car.gOscillation plane of a Fucault pendulum located elsewhere turns 2n sin a radians perday, where a is the latitude of the place.


諾貝爾物理學獎得主海姆對得獎‘表詫異稱如常工作

10月 5, 2010
今屆諾貝爾物理學獎,由英國曼徹斯特大學,兩位俄裔學者海姆和諾沃肖洛夫奪得,表揚他們在新物料「石墨烯」方面開創性的研究,兩人將分享一百五十萬美元的獎金;石墨烯是非常薄的碳,厚度只有一粒原子,瑞典皇家科學院說,兩人對石墨烯的研究,有助研發新物料,以及創新電子學;五十一歲的海姆接受訪問時說,對得獎感到詫異,但今日會如常工作,三十六歲的諾沃肖洛夫,則是其中一位最年輕的諾貝爾獎得主。 海姆及諾沃肖洛夫在二零零四年合作制成石墨烯材料,這種材料具高度穩定性,導電性良好,適合製造透明的輕觸式屏幕,甚至是太陽能電池;海姆擁有荷蘭國籍,諾沃肖洛夫則同時持有英國和俄羅斯居留權。

在 WordPress.com 上免费创建您自己的网站。创建您自己的网站。
免费开始